Can Cat Eat Sugar? Here's the Real Answer
Dog cake 10 Minutes Read

Can Cat Eat Sugar? Here's the Real Answer

It is easy to assume that if something smells good to us, it might appeal to our pets too. Cats, in particular, seem curious about whatever we are eating. This is especially true if it’s something like cake, biscuits, or sweet-smelling snacks. 

So, we understand that it is natural to wonder: Can cats eat sugar? Is a little bit okay?

For example, if you’re celebrating and thinking of letting your cat have a bite of your own cake, it’s worth stopping to think — is that really suitable as a cat birthday cake? Let’s take a proper look at what sugar means for cats and what’s actually safe.

Why Sugar Is Not for Cats

Cats don’t actually taste sweetness the way we do. They lack the taste receptors for sugar, which means sweet foods hold no appeal from a flavour perspective. Nonetheless, more important here is that their bodies don’t need sugar at all. In fact, in many cases, sugar can do more harm than good.

Too much sugar or even a small amount for a cat may lead to:

  • Stomach upset
  • Lethargy
  • Weight gain
  • Dental problems
  • Over time, even diabetes

Cats are obligate carnivores. They are built for digesting animal protein and fat, not carbohydrates and sugar. So, giving your cat a sweet treat may feel like kindness, but it could leave them feeling sick.

How Sugar Affects a Cat’s Body

Unlike humans and even dogs to some extent, cats have no need for sugar in their diet and no ability to benefit from it. Their bodies are not designed to break down or make use of glucose from non-meat sources.

Let’s take a look:

Effect

In Cats

In Dogs

Taste for sweetness

Absent — no sweet taste receptors

Present — but still no nutritional need

Digestive ability

Poor — very low carbohydrate tolerance

Limited — sugar can still cause issues

Sugar use as energy

Not effective

Not recommended — processed differently

Health risks

Obesity, diabetes, fatty liver, dental issues

Obesity, digestive problems, tooth decay

Cats rely on high-protein, low-carb diets. Giving them sugar interrupts that balance. And because they can’t taste it, they gain nothing from it, not even enjoyment.

Which Everyday Foods Might Have Sugar in Them?

Not all sugar comes in the obvious form. You might not give your cat a slice of your sponge cake, but many common household foods contain sugars you may not spot right away.

Here are a few to keep an eye on:

  • Breakfast cereals
  • Flavoured yoghurts
  • Bread
  • Condiments like ketchup
  • Some peanut butters

Even some pet-friendly treats on supermarket shelves contain ingredients like dextrose, syrup solids, or molasses — all sugar-based. Hence, always read the label.

If you’re ever unsure, stick to freshly prepared, species-appropriate treats like cat cupcakes or a small cat birthday cake made without sugar or artificial additives.

Are There Sugars in Pet Treats I Should Be Avoiding?

Yes — and not just the white sugar you put in your coffee.

Some commercial pet treats include sweeteners to improve texture or shelf life. These might not be listed clearly as "sugar," but appear under different names like:

  • Sucrose
  • Glucose
  • Corn syrup
  • Fructose
  • Dextrose
  • Maltodextrin

These are all forms of sugar. Plus, none of them are necessary or healthy in a cat’s diet. As a matter of fact, they can cause digestive upset and long-term issues such as insulin resistance.

That’s why at Supaw, every cat cake and treat is made without sugar or artificial sweeteners. Do you need it for a birthday or just a small celebration? No matter what, there’s no reason a treat needs to come with health risks.

And for households with both cats and dogs, you can relax because cakes made at our canine bakery are separate for each. We only use ingredients tailored to suit their individual needs.

How Can I Celebrate Without Giving My Cat Sugar?

Celebrating your cat doesn’t mean compromising their health. The safest way to include your cat in a special moment is with a cake or treat made for their body and their digestion.

That’s where sugar-free cat birthday cake options come in.

What goes into a pet-safe cat cake?

  • Human-grade chicken, tuna, ocean fish, or beef
  • Coconut flour and coconut milk for binding and texture 
  • Gentle and natural colours from vegetables like turmeric or beetroot

At Supaw, our cat cakes Melbourne range is baked fresh using pet-safe ingredients. No fillers, no grains, no sweeteners — just a properly made treat that won’t upset your cat’s system.

And while our kitchen also prepares cakes, treats, and cupcakes for dogs, every order is species-specific. Cakes for cats and dogs are made separately to meet their unique needs. So, if you have both pets, you can celebrate safely, with peace of mind.

What Cat Owners Often Get Wrong About Sugar

Some pet owners assume that a “lick” of icing or a “tiny taste” of cake is harmless. But for cats, even small amounts of the wrong ingredient can be problematic, especially if offered regularly.

Here are a few misconceptions worth clearing up:

  • “It’s just a little sugar.”

→ Cats don’t need any. Zero is better than a little.

  • “I only give it to them once a year.”

→ Digestive reactions don’t follow a schedule. It only takes one time.

  • “They seem to enjoy it.”

→ Cats can’t taste sweetness. If they’re eating it, it’s out of curiosity, not preference.

That’s why choosing something tailored — like our cat cakes Melbourne range — is the better option.

Celebrate the Right Way, Without Sugar

Cats don’t need sugar, and it doesn’t belong in their treats. Whether it’s a daily reward or something special like a cat birthday cake, ingredients should match their needs. They should be: 

  • High in protein
  • Easy to digest
  • Free from unnecessary fillers

At Supaw, every cat cake is baked using fresh ingredients and nothing artificial. Our recipes are simple and carefully prepared for cats only — no grains, no sugar, and no crossover with dog products.

If you're after proper cat cakes Melbourne can trust, or a reliable canine bakery that understands the difference, you’ll find both with us.

Back to blog